As the age of armory construction in post-civil war America arrived, the Veteran’s Association sought to join other large cities and build their own medieval style armory in the city of Boston.
The Veterans Association needed to raise the $687,000 (apx $16,000,00 today) for the armory. Half of the funds were raised through private donations from wealthy Bostonians and the half was from the profits of cadet musicals.
Many of the new cadets recruited by LTC Edmands had attended Harvard University and had participated in the Hasty Pudding Club which gave them experience performing. They performed a variety of different shows, and a FCC member Robert Barnet wrote and produced a series of musicals that proved to be wildly popular with Boston’s avid theater goers.
With a bankroll of over $16 million dollars, the architect William Gibbons Preston, who was also a member of the FCC, created quite a fortress, with its six-story head house, a 200 foot long drill hall, and its many unique details: triple doors to protect against mob attacks, a drawbridge, windows with iron shutters, and a flag to fly over its crenellated roofline at the corner of Columbus and Arlington (the castle formally Smith and Wollensky Steakhouse) with a flagpole held by a stone griffin with wings outspread.
The castle remained in the ownership of the VAFCC until 1968, when the building was sold because the VAFCC could not pay for the modernizing repair work needed to maintain the castle. the VAFCC purchased a five-story brownstone on Commonwealth Avenue with its profits from the sale, where it presently houses the museum of the FCC.